It is a global creative effectiveness study (Q1 2024) from Pinterest and System1 that shows how the emotion and attention generated by Promoted Pins relate to brand and sales results. System1’s Test Your Ad metrics were correlated with return on ad spend (ROAS) and sales lift from Pinterest’s US third-party sales lift meta-analysis, and with EMEA brand lift results, to reveal what makes digital creative work harder.
Pinterest isolated 67 Promoted Pins from 35 studies within a meta-analysis of 85 US third-party sales lift studies (2021–2022) in the consumer packaged goods (CPG) sector. Categories covered were food, beverage, beauty/cosmetics, personal care/OTC, baby, homecare and pet food. The sample included:
System1 measured every Pin using Test Your Ad with a nationally representative US audience and with US Pinterest users, totaling over 20,000 US respondents. The same Pins were shown to both audiences. System1 also coded each Pin’s creative features blind, without knowing the results, and combined this with a similar meta-analysis of Pinterest EMEA CPG brand lift studies (Q3 2020–Q1 2022) to understand emotion’s impact on ad recall and brand lift.
Three key metrics were measured for all 67 Pins:
The study also reports Fast Fluency, which reflects how quickly viewers correctly recognize the brand.
Yes. Compared with the US general population, Pinterest users produced statistically significantly higher responses across all metrics. They showed 12% more happiness, 11% less neutrality and 27% more emotional intensity, alongside a 1.1 increase in Star Rating and an 18% increase in Fast Fluency. Pinterest users also paid attention for longer and were more emotionally engaged, which can lead to greater rapid brand recognition.
Pinterest users’ response was even stronger for video. Compared with the general population, they showed 14% more happiness, 14% less neutrality, 39% more emotional intensity and a 39% increase in Fast Fluency. Star Rating for video content rose by 1.3, suggesting video on Pinterest can create more positive, longer-lasting effects.
Yes. Ads that elicited a positive human response, identified by an above-average Star Rating, outperformed those with a below-average Star Rating on both brand and sales measures:
In short, ads that leave Pinterest users feeling more positive can help grow both brand and sales effectiveness.
Yes. Ads that attract and sustain more Creative Attention saw improved sales outcomes: 2.7x higher ROAS and 1.3x higher sales lift, when indexed against the median average view time across the analysis. The more creatively engaging the ad, the stronger the effects.
System1 analyzed a sample of EMEA ads for two types of creative features, drawing on Orlando Wood’s “Look Out” research with the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (2021). Narrow Beam features assume the viewer’s interest, while Broad Beam features attract and sustain broad attention.
Yes. Ads with more Broad Beam features saw greater increases in brand lift metrics, including a 90% higher lift in Brand Favorability. Using Broad Beam features to elicit more intense positive emotions and sustain more Creative Attention was shown to boost ad recall, brand lift and ROAS.
The study identified seven practices that raise Star Rating or Creative Attention:
Heavy on-screen text hurts performance. Pins that relied heavily on text that obtrudes and obscures the creative, getting in the way of the visuals, decreased average Star Rating by 0.5 and Creative Attention by 95%. The guidance is to use fewer words and more visuals to increase attention and elicit more positive emotion.
Yes. Featuring the living delivered the largest increase seen in the study: putting people, animals and babies into the creative increased average Star Rating by 1.2. Pins featuring humans showing sudden, visible changes in facial expression had an average +0.5 Star Rating, helping to boost positive emotion.
Four features were linked to higher Creative Attention:
Two brands featured in the report show how Pinterest creative can drive results (figures below are from Pinterest and the advertisers, not System1’s creative analysis):
System1’s Test Your Ad Digital measures the emotional response, attention and early brand recognition that drive effectiveness, so you can predict and improve the performance of every element of a campaign. You can test among the general population or use custom samples to gain insights from specific target audiences.