Creative Consistency? Priceless. MasterCard Proves It Again

Mastercard

Together Is Better

3.5

Make creative your competitive edge; unlock insights and inspiration from 100,000+ ads, rooted in emotional response, to predict and improve your creative’s business impact. Access every Ad Of The Week in our Topical Ads categories.

Welcome to our new US Ad Of The Month feature, where we take a deep dive on a high-performing new ad. Each month we’ll be looking at the topline Test Your Ad results but going deeper into the diagnostics and exploring how the ad compares on our Competitive Edge database.

We’re starting with Mastercard, who are promoting their new Mastercard Collection, a suite of benefits available to their higher-tier global members, including exclusive discounts on top hotels, travel destinations and restaurants. Their new ad “Together Is Better” boasts top-tier Brand Fluency and lands in the top 5% of the Credit Services category, testament to how well creative consistency has worked for them.

It’s been almost 30 years since Mastercard transformed credit card advertising with their Priceless campaign, the first credit card ads to move beyond features and availability and really go for the emotional benefits of membership. Priceless was a phenomenal success, growing Mastercard’s market share, and the insights that drive it are still relevant today.

At the heart of the campaign is the idea that Mastercard offers its customers the freedom to experience moments that are truly precious, and that’s as powerful a selling point now as it was in 1997. The new ad still uses “Priceless” as its tagline.

“Together Is Better” presents that insight in a relaxing, unhurried way, with an unusual collage technique switching between stills and video as a voiceover describes how a pair of siblings fly out to New York for a reunion with their sister, who’s built a career and an adult life there. It takes no time at all for the three of them to be back laughing together like they did as kids – and it’s the Mastercard Collection that allowed these moments of family joy to happen.

While Priceless opened the door to more emotional ads in the Credit Services category, other brands have not always taken advantage. The sector as a whole still has only a 1.9-Star Rating average, meaning that most Credit Services ads are simply not a good brand growth investment.

Mastercard’s ad scores 3.5-Stars, a good score in any category but in the top 5% of this underperforming sector. It’s also Mastercard’s best performing ad in the last 4 years, showing how strongly the “Priceless” idea still resonates when matched to an emotional story. Short-term Spike Rating, and Emotional Intensity, are also good scores and both are way over the category average.

In the Test Your Ad report we can also break down the key moments in the ad – its peak of Happiness in the closing shot of the family united around a dining table at 49s, and the early spike in Fluency as the collage section makes sure to show the Mastercard logo prominently.

In fact it’s Brand Fluency where the ad really stands out, with a huge 96% recognition putting “Together Is Better” in the top 2% of ads in the Credit Services category, and making it Mastercard’s most fluent ad of the decade.

It’s not hard to see where this strong branding comes from. There’s discreet use of the logos and branding all through the ad, but the emotional peak comes when the voiceover drops the “Priceless” tagline at the end. It’s not just that the insight remains strong after three decades, it’s that consistent use of the same creative idea has generated enormous brand recognition and cultural footprint. When you have an ad which uses that well – and “Together Is Better” certainly does – it’s a recipe for effectiveness. Creative consistency really is priceless.

Create 5-star ads

The more people feel, the more they buy

The most effective ads boost sales and drive long-term growth. They do it by making people feel more - building positive associations with a recognisable brand. We predict sales and growth impacts by measuring emotion, letting you make ads that entertain for commercial gain.

Try Test Your Ad
FANCY A CLOSER LOOK?

Request a demo
with one of our experts

Complete the form to book your demo.

  • Discuss your use cases and business needs
  • Our expert will give a hands-on demonstration of the platform
  • We’ll show how deep consumer insights can guide your marketing strategy